3 Comments
User's avatar
Miloslaus_Joseph's avatar

This is a topic that, even within the Catholic Church, is often pushed out of the consciousness of the faithful. Instead, a "gospel of success" and constant happiness is promoted—an idea of ​​building heaven on earth—which misleads believers into thinking that suffering must be rejected. Spiritually, this is depleting and destructive; it leaves us unable to cope with or understand suffering, and often leads people to turn away from God, under the assumption that He is the one meting out such punishments. Your text, however, captures—in a very simple way—the true source of our happiness and the goal toward which we strive here on earth: union with God, who is the only Healer, the only true happiness, and the ultimate meaning of our earthly lives.

Observing the reactions of others—as well as our own behavior—in the face of such experiences reveals the true nature of our faith and our underlying motivations. We look to individuals, institutions, therapists, podcasts, and everything else the world has to offer in an attempt to break free from our state of suffering, yet we fail to turn toward the One who is our true refuge and help—the One in whom we can heal our wounds. He Himself invites us to come to Him—all who are weary and burdened—promising that He will give us rest. In reality, it is through these failed attempts and stumbles that God leads us toward Himself, helping us finally realize that He alone can help us, and that suffering is, in fact, a path leading to Him. Looking at the teachings of the Desert Fathers, the Holy Doctors, and the Fathers of the Catholic Church, our life comes down to one thing: a categorical choice—either God or nothing. If we view suffering through the prism of eternal life and stop deluding ourselves that life on earth is some kind of "second heaven," then we can truly receive the grace to know God more closely and to live in union with Him.

I always keep in mind the words of Abba Anthony:

“Whoever has not experienced temptation cannot enter into the Kingdom of Heaven. He even added, ‘Without temptations no one can be saved.’”

Temptations are also a form of suffering—be it lesser or greater—but this is how the Lord God tests those whom He has loved, much like gold is tested in the fire. The Book of Sirach says exactly the same thing: "My son, if you aspire to serve the Lord, prepare your soul for trials."

Michael Rucker's avatar

Wonderful comments brother. Glad you enjoyed the article and thanks for the encouragement!

Miloslaus_Joseph's avatar

Thank you for your kind words.

Your article is truly a breath of fresh air in a Catholic space otherwise filled with cotton candy, assurances of salvation for the deceased, the "gospel of success," and a version of mercy straight out of the series *The Chosen*. The level of saccharine sweetness currently served up—even during Sunday homilies—has become unbearable for me. On the other hand, I also encounter priests who go to the opposite extreme, dramatizing things to an excessive degree and frightening the faithful—not so much with hell, but with demonic possession and spiritual bondage. They suggest that if, for instance, your aunt were to say to you in a fit of anger, "Go to the devil!", God would instantly withdraw from you, and the devil would claim you as his own property.

In an era that the media deceitfully portrays as a "golden age"—an age of prosperity, progress, a focus on mental health, and an abundance of comforts and opportunities—the subject of suffering is, in my view, more necessary than ever. We Catholics, in particular, are increasingly falling for the illusion that suffering is not an inherent part of our faith, thereby drifting dangerously close to Protestant perspectives.

Furthermore, the topic of suffering is often presented incorrectly; it is not rooted in the authentic teaching and tradition of the Catholic Church, but rather increasingly based on the subjective feelings and personal experiences of individual priests—or anyone else speaking on the subject. It seems to me that this relates to something written by Saint Benedicta of the Cross:

"Whoever wishes to be wedded to the Lamb must allow themselves to be nailed to the cross along with Him. All those marked by the Blood of the Lamb—that is, all the baptized—are called to this, yet not everyone understands His summons. To follow Christ means to imitate Him with ever-greater faithfulness; this call resonates piercingly within the soul and demands an unequivocal response"

What strikes one most forcibly in this quote is that God demands an unequivocal response from us, provided we truly wish to become like Him. Our entire life boils down to this very choice: either God, or nothing. There is no other path; in my view, suffering serves as a purifying fire, leading us toward union with God’s will. It is then that we truly arrive at the source of the truth: that whatever may happen in our lives—be it good or bad, suffering or joy, health or illness, wealth or poverty—is ultimately of no consequence, because only God matters, and we accept everything without falling into extremes.

Many saints write about this in their works as the final stage, in which they find rest in God—for God alone suffices, and nothing from the world can disturb this peace.