Why do you believe in the existence of a God? Reason is the dividing line between delusion and reality. Through exploring the sciences and examining evidence, we learn how to do proper reasoning, all in hopes that it will lead us to the right conclusions about reality. Ultimately, it is on these conclusions that we ground our trust.
There are many arguments for the existence of God that result from both science and logical reasoning, some of which take much effort to deduce. For me, however, the most effective argument for the existence of God is not one that starts with a claim about what is, but instead displays what we undisputably lack. Think of it this way: the best way to sell someone a product is not to first show him the cost, but to show him his need. A man will pay anything for what he wants most. Therefore, in my book, the most effective argument for the existence of God is the argument from mankind’s universal, endless pursuit of satisfaction.
A Universal Pursuit of Pleasure
I have always had a desire for more. Nothing satisfies it. I eat a meal, but then always get hungry again. I enjoy winning a competition, but then I’m onto craving the next goal. I try a new job, but it’s never perfect. I clean the house, but it somehow gets messy again. You get the point. Man is perpetually seeking after perfection, order, pleasure, happiness, satisfaction, etc. However, nothing seems to grant it completely.
Aristotle calls this perfect delight that we crave the highest good of man. In his opening statements of his primary work, Nicomachean Ethics, he claims,
“every action and pursuit, is thought to aim at some good; and for this reason the good has rightly been declared to be that at which all things aim…But where such arts fall under a single capacity…the ends of the master arts are to be preferred to all the subordinate ends; for it is for the sake of the former that the latter are pursued…If, then, there is some end of the things we do, which we desire for its own sake (everything else being desired for the sake of this), and if we do not choose everything for the sake of something else (for at that rate the process would go on to infinity, so that our desire would be empty and vain), clearly this must be the good and the chief good” (Aristotle, Book 1.1).
In essence, Aristotle notes that every pursuit, by desire or by action, aims at meeting some good in its completion. He determined that there must be some final good for which every other good is pursued. Additionally, that which is the highest good is the object which is in itself most valuable.
Later, this concept was popularized by Roman orator and philosopher Marcus Tullius Cicero. Daniel Dal Monte, Ph.D., observes Cicero’s understanding of the highest good, stating,
“It is not as though we move from good to good, with no higher unity connecting our various experiences…Underlying all these activities is an aspiration towards a state of complete flourishing and beatitude, i.e. happiness” (Dal Monte).
Dal Monte affirms Cicero’s argument that for any of our pursuits toward happiness to have actual meaning, they are contingent on the existence of a singular highest good, an end in which all desires properly ordered will rest as satisfied. Therefore, the highest good is the resting place of desire because it supplies the best possible state of being for man, and the pursuit of it is equal to the pursuit of true and final happiness.
Why Nothing In This Life Satisfies
To summarize: humans want to be satisfied, and not just a little satisfied, but perfectly satisfied. Otherwise, we would not build houses to keep us safe, or seek out food to fill our stomachs. The problem is that nothing on earth has ever satisfied perfectly, specifically because of our lack of permanency. How can something be said to be truly satisfactory if it does not satisfy in full, but only so long as effort is applied to preserve the upkeep of its pleasure? Indeed, it cannot be said to satisfy fully, but merely temporarily. For to exert perpetual effort in pursuit of satisfaction is not to live in final blessedness (happiness).
For this reason, that we are always desiring the permanency of his satisfaction, it becomes clear to us that there must be something external to this life that we are in want of. But how could he be in want of something we have never possessed? For example: how can a man desire a woman he has never met? How can a man desire the food he has never tasted? It is right to say that he cannot, unless he is by his very nature ordered toward the enjoyment of such a thing.
Desires Reveal Something About Reality
C.S. Lewis treats this in his work The Weight of Glory when he states,
“...we remain conscious of a desire which no natural happiness will satisfy. But is there any reason to suppose that reality offers any satisfaction to it? ‘Nor does the being hungry prove that we have bread.’ But I think it may be urged that this misses the point. A man’s physical hunger does not prove that he will get any bread; he may die of starvation on a raft in the Atlantic. But surely a man’s hunger does prove that he comes from a race which repairs its body by eating and inhabits a world where eatable substances exist. In the same way, though I do not believe that my desire for Paradise proves that I shall enjoy it, I think it a pretty good indication that such a thing exists and that some men will” (Lewis, pg. 32).
To Lewis, the idea is that man has a craving for what he does not possess is evidence of what he is rightly ordered toward. However, this does not mean that the object onto which one’s desires are then mapped will inevitably be the efficient object to satisfy. We often direct our desires toward what we foolishly think will satisfy our craving.
We live this reality constantly, experiencing hunger and in turn craving a filling dinner. But then, when we reach the last bite of our meal, we recognize that we wish we had more to eat. So then we proceed to dessert in hopes of finally satisfying our appetite. This reality doesn’t mean that the main course didn’t fill some space in one’s stomach. But it does mean that the main course was not efficient in serving what the desire hoped to receive from it. The necessary conclusion then would be that there was something which would have satisfied us which we failed to grasp.
Lewis uses the same logic to affirm his point, saying,
“A man may love a woman and not win her; but it would be very odd if the phenomenon called ‘falling in love’ occurred in a sexless world” (The Weight of Glory, pg. 33). To refer back to the illustration of procreation,
Desires must be directed at their proper object for the fulfillment of their hoped-for end. Desires do not mean on their own that we will always direct the desire at the correct object. However, they certainly affirm that the reality of a properly satisfying object must exist.
Scripture Reveals The One Who Satisfies Fully
So, the desire for complete satisfaction necessitates the existence of an efficient supplier of it. The Bible speaks of God in this way, stating,
“You make known to me the path of life; in your presence there is fullness of joy; at your right hand are pleasures forevermore” (Ps. 16:11, ESV).
First, God himself is shown to be the fullness of the desire for pleasure we have. The ache within us which leads us all to desire something fully satisfying is meant to lead us to who truly possesses fullness: God himself. Additionally, David shows the permanency of the pleasure to be had in God. The craving for satisfaction, not just momentarily, but forever, is found in God alone!
So, in conclusion. I believe that the best argument for the existence of God is not one which shows what is plain to the eye, for scripture shows us that even plain evidence is insufficient to those who “suppress the knowledge of the truth” and “exchange the truth for a lie” (Romans 1). Rather, the most effective argument for the existence of God is the one which calls man into what he was made for: perfect delight in union with God, the only one who can truly satisfy.



Lovely! I enjoyed how you mapped Aristotelian philosophy -> Lewis -> Union with God; can't go wrong with that sequence.
You would love Boethius's argument in On the Consolation of Philosophy; your reflection reminded me of his argument. Essentially, he says we all desire the good, but the problem with the good in this world is twofold: it is either imperfect or temporal, or both. What we truly yearn for is a good that is neither temporal nor imperfect. In other words, we yearn and need an infinite, perfect, everlasting good. Only God can fit that definition.